Back to Blogs
Why Diversity Still Matters In Leadership Hiring
Share this Article

Why Diversity Still Matters in Leadership Hiring

  • Publish Date: Posted 10 days ago

​We’ve been talking about Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) for years now—but when it comes to real change, it has to start at the top. Leadership sets the tone for an entire organization. The values they champion, the decisions they make, and the teams they build ripple through every level of a company. That’s why diverse leadership isn’t just a “nice to have”—it’s a game-changer.

Decade of research keeps telling us the same story: companies with inclusive leadership teams are more innovative, more profitable, and better equipped to handle challenges. And yet, barriers to leadership diversity still exist, often baked into outdated systems and habits. So how do we move the needle? It starts with understanding the data—and then using it to drive intentional, lasting change.

Innovation Thrives in Inclusive Environments

Let’s be real—diversity isn’t just about checking boxes or looking good in a company photo. It’s about performance. Decades of research have made one thing crystal clear: companies with diverse leadership teams don’t just do better, they win.

Take McKinsey & Company’s 2020 report, Diversity Wins. They found that companies with gender-diverse executive teams were 25% more likely to outperform their peers on profitability. And if the leadership team was ethnically and culturally diverse? That number jumped to 36%. That’s not a fluke—it’s a pattern. When everyone at the top looks and thinks the same, growth stalls. But when you mix in different perspectives, experiences, and backgrounds? That’s where the magic happens.

And it’s not just about profits—it’s about ideas. According to a Boston Consulting Group study (The Mix That Matters), companies with above-average diversity in management generated 19% more revenue from innovation than their less-diverse counterparts. Why? Because when your team mirrors the real world, you see opportunities others miss. You avoid blind spots. You build solutions that speak to a broader audience.

What’s Holding Us Back?
So if the business case is this strong, why aren’t we seeing faster change? Because deep-rooted barriers are still in play:

  • Unconscious Bias: It’s subtle but powerful. Résumés with “ethnic-sounding” names still get fewer callbacks. We all carry bias—it’s what we do about it that counts.

  • The Broken Pipeline: Systemic inequities in education, mentorship, and opportunity often block underrepresented talent from even reaching leadership tracks.

  • Retention Gaps: Even when diverse talent gets through the door, they don’t always stay. According to McKinsey’s Women in the Workplace 2022, women leaders are leaving faster than men, citing burnout and feeling undervalued.

What Can We Actually Do About It?

The good news? Change is possible—and there are concrete steps that work:

  • Widen the Talent Search: Partner with universities, women’s leadership programmes, and agencies focused on diverse hiring. Cast a wider net.

  • Make Hiring More Objective: Blind CV reviews and skills-based assessments help eliminate bias from the get-go.

  • Mentorship That Matters: Create sponsorship programmes that help underrepresented talent rise through the ranks with real support and advocacy.

  • Build Inclusive Cultures: Psychological safety is key. Make inclusion part of performance reviews and hold leaders accountable for creating safe, welcoming environments.

  • Measure What Matters: Track your progress. Share the data. Tie leadership compensation to real inclusion outcomes.

The Road Ahead: Still a Ways to Go

Recent LinkedIn data (2024) shows we’re not there yet. Women still hold only 32% of leadership roles globally—and the biggest drop-off happens right when careers should be accelerating, from senior contributor to manager. Women of colour, LGBTQ+ individuals, and people with disabilities face even steeper challenges.

The message? There’s work to do. But it’s doable—with intention, transparency, and commitment.

Let’s Be Clear: Diversity Is Strategy

At the end of the day, this isn’t just about doing the right thing—it’s about doing the smart thing. Companies that prioritize diverse, inclusive leadership consistently outperform those that don’t. Why? Because when leadership reflects a range of perspectives and lived experiences, teams are more innovative, agile, and better prepared to meet the challenges of a rapidly changing world.

By dismantling outdated systems, creating equitable pathways to leadership, and fostering cultures where everyone feels they belong, we unlock the full potential of our people—and our business.

Diverse leadership isn’t a “nice to have.” It’s a strategic necessity.

Looking to build a leadership team that’s ready for what’s next? Our recruitment experts can help you find the right leaders to guide your organization through change—and into long-term success. Let’s connect.

​

References